Some people prefer to keep their shoes on when they enter their home, while others like to take them off and go barefoot or wear slippers. But what does science say about this common household dilemma? Is there a health or hygiene benefit to leaving your shoes at the door, or is it just a matter of personal preference and comfort?
▪The case for shoe removal
According to some environmental chemists, there are plenty of reasons to remove your shoes before entering your home. They argue that shoes can carry a variety of contaminants from the outside environment, such as dirt, dust, bacteria, viruses, toxins, and metals. These contaminants can accumulate on your floors, carpets, and furniture, and pose a potential risk to your health and the health of your pets and children.
For example, a study by the University of Arizona found that shoes can harbor an average of 421,000 bacteria, including Escherichia coli (E. coli), which can cause intestinal and urinary tract infections, and Staphylococcus aureus, which can cause skin infections and pneumonia¹. Another study by Baylor University found that shoes can also track in coal tar, a common pavement sealant that contains polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), which are carcinogenic substances². Moreover, shoes can bring in pesticides, herbicides, and fertilizers from lawns and gardens, which can disrupt the endocrine system and affect the reproductive and developmental health³.
Therefore, removing your shoes at the door can help reduce the exposure to these harmful substances and keep your indoor environment cleaner and safer.
▪The case for shoe wearing
On the other hand, some people may argue that wearing shoes in the home is not a big deal, and that the benefits of shoe removal are exaggerated or inconclusive. They may point out that the levels of contaminants on shoes are not high enough to cause significant health problems, and that the human immune system is capable of fighting off most germs and infections. They may also cite other sources of indoor pollution, such as cooking, smoking, cleaning products, and pets, that may contribute more to the indoor air quality than shoes.
Additionally, some people may prefer to wear shoes in the home for comfort, convenience, or cultural reasons. For instance, some people may have foot conditions, such as plantar fasciitis or diabetes, that require them to wear supportive footwear at all times. Some people may also find it easier to slip on and off their shoes when they need to go in and out of the house frequently. Furthermore, some people may consider it rude or disrespectful to ask their guests to remove their shoes, especially if they come from different cultural backgrounds or have different personal preferences.
Therefore, wearing shoes in the home can be a matter of choice and convenience, and not necessarily a health hazard.
▪The verdict
So, what is the best practice for shoes in the home? The answer may depend on your individual situation and preference, as well as the type and frequency of your outdoor activities. However, based on the current scientific evidence, it seems that removing your shoes at the door can have some benefits for reducing the amount of contaminants and germs in your home, especially if you have young children, pets, or people with compromised immune systems. If you decide to keep your shoes on, you may want to clean them regularly and avoid walking on carpets or furniture. You may also want to respect the wishes of your host or guest when you visit someone else's home, and follow their shoe policy.
Ultimately, the choice is yours, but it may be worth considering the pros and cons of shoes in the home, and making an informed decision that suits your lifestyle and comfort.
0 Comments